Burn Testing: A Dangerous Occupation
Luckily, I came prepared:
Indulged my inner pyro:
Cotton |
Jute |
Sheep Wool |
Dog Hair |
Mohair |
Mystery Fibre |
Evidence:
Results
Fibre
|
Catch
light easily?
|
Sustain
flame?
|
Smells
like burning...
|
Residue
|
cotton
|
yes
|
yes
|
marshmallows
|
none
|
jute
|
yes
|
strong even in breeze, smouldered aggressively
after flame extinguished
|
wood
|
grey, silky, fragile
|
wool
|
no
|
no
|
meat
|
black, crumbly
|
dog
hair
|
no
|
no
|
meat
|
“
|
mohair
85%, 15% acrylic
|
no
|
no
|
meat
|
“
|
polyamide (nylon)
|
slow
|
yes, durable in breeze
|
meaty plastic
|
sticky until cold, black, shiny, brittle
|
acrylic
|
yes
|
yes, travelled quickly
|
plastic
|
“
|
acrylic
91%, rayon 9%
|
yes
|
yes, aggressive when travelling up yarn
|
plastic
|
“
|
unknown
(product tag tie)
|
yes
|
yes
|
plastic
|
yarn too fine to leave enough residue
to evaluate
|
unknown
(blind cord)
|
no
|
yes, vigorous when sheltered
|
sour plastic
|
sticky until cold, brown and black,
shiny, hard
|
The tag tie behaved very much like the acrylic yarns. The blind cord was unique; it must have been a fibre or blend that I haven't tested. I wonder if it was polypropylene?
How might these yarns be used?
Cotton: makes nearly non-stretch woven and crocheted fabrics; knitted, it stretches a lot, especially on the bias and on ribbed features such as cuffs, neck and waistband. It has no recovery until washed in hot water or put through the dryer. It is easy to wash and dry, but will shrink on first washing. Doesn't require ironing (in this weight of yarn) and is very durable, but it stains easily and fades. Moulds if put away damp. Cold when damp. This type of cotton yarn is best used for craft items, utility pieces such as bags and mats, and informal clothing such as pullovers and slippers. Not warm enough to use for protective winter wear.
Jute: is also non stretch, but it is very coarse and rough, not suitable for garments or items such as bag straps that will be in contact with skin. Mildews if left damp, but it tends to shed so it is typically not washed. Not strong enough to be used where safety is a concern as it frays easily. Useful for rustic decorative items and gardening.
Wool: makes a naturally stretchy and resilient knit and a stable woven. If not labelled superwash, it requires standard wool-washing procedures but not an unreasonable amount of care. Naturally a little moisture resistant, wool is not as likely as cotton to be stained, but stains are possible. Does not need to be washed often, but must be shaken and well aired before storing. Should be properly cleaned and dried before long term storage. Should be stored with moth prevention. Colourfast. Can wrinkle, but these are easy to steam out. Warm when damp. This yarn would be fine for handknitted items; it is also an appropriate weight for a hand-operated knitting machine. Suitable for garments and textile art.
Mo (angora goat): very slippery fibre that needs to be spun with a binder to keep it together. Can felt very easily, so requires cautious washing. Colourfast. Tends to shed hairs almost as much as the dog! Can be knit, woven or felted. Produces fluffy fabrics that are very warm for their weight. Useful for people with chronic pain who find the weight of winter clothing a problem. Takes colour almost as brilliantly as silk so it tends to be prized by textile artists. Handles well on a knitting machine.
Dog: less stretchy and resilient than wool; produces a slacker fabric that has less body. Requires more caution in washing than wool. Colourfast. May itch or produce allergic reactions in some wearers. Suitable for knits or wovens, but I didn't have more than four inches of yarn from my dog, and half of it is burnt now, so...
Polyamide and acrylic: these particular examples are all slippery, droopy yarns with little body. They will produce slippery, droopy fabrics, although most acrylic yarns sold in stores are different in character, having been produced to imitate wool. They are machine washable and dryable with moderate heat, but should not be ironed. Ironing is unlikely to be necessary because they don't hold a crease. Stain resistant and colourfast. Bought to do projects at other people's request, I have little interest in using them myself as I usually prefer natural fibres to work with.
Helpful Resources
Melville, S. (n.d.). Techniques every knitter should know (online video course). Retrieved from
http://www.craftsy.com/class/essential-techniques-every-knitter-should-know/3997?_ct=sbqii-sqjuweho-qbb&_ctp=3997,1
Parkes, C. (n.d.). Know your yarn (online video course). Retrieved from
http://www.craftsy.com/class/know-your-yarn-choose-the-perfect-yarn-every-time/3909?_ct=sbqii-sqjuweho-qbb&_ctp=3909,23
Werker, K. (n.d.). Crochet basics and beyond (online video course). Retrieved from
http://www.craftsy.com/class/crochet-basics-and-beyond/4728?_ct=sbqii-sqjuweho-dum&_ctp=2
How to clean wool. (n.d.). Retrieved from
http://www.howtocleanstuff.net/how-to-clean-wool/
Stain removal. (n.d.). Vancouver, BC: David Suzuki Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.davidsuzuki.org/publications/downloads/2012/qog-stainremoval.pdf
Helpful Resources
Melville, S. (n.d.). Techniques every knitter should know (online video course). Retrieved from
http://www.craftsy.com/class/essential-techniques-every-knitter-should-know/3997?_ct=sbqii-sqjuweho-qbb&_ctp=3997,1
Parkes, C. (n.d.). Know your yarn (online video course). Retrieved from
http://www.craftsy.com/class/know-your-yarn-choose-the-perfect-yarn-every-time/3909?_ct=sbqii-sqjuweho-qbb&_ctp=3909,23
Werker, K. (n.d.). Crochet basics and beyond (online video course). Retrieved from
http://www.craftsy.com/class/crochet-basics-and-beyond/4728?_ct=sbqii-sqjuweho-dum&_ctp=2
How to clean wool. (n.d.). Retrieved from
http://www.howtocleanstuff.net/how-to-clean-wool/
Stain removal. (n.d.). Vancouver, BC: David Suzuki Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.davidsuzuki.org/publications/downloads/2012/qog-stainremoval.pdf
Great chart Heather, very useful!
ReplyDeleteVery thorough; well done, Heather. I appreciated the Danger Zone sign at the top of your post.
ReplyDeleteHi Heather. (I just lost my comments so will post again). I am really interested in the mo and dog hair fibres. A number of years ago I knew someone who knitted a pair of mittens with the hair of their dog (I forget the breed). They felt very interesting but I think it's a largely nostalgic item and not something for a market. I'm also interested in the angora fibre. There is a cashmere goat farm near me and the items she makes are beautiful but they are very tricky to gather as they must be collected every day instead of the "big harvest" that shearing allows. A really teachable resource you collected. I especially like how you were precise in your descriptions and your photos were so clear in what they were showing. Well done! Brenda
ReplyDeleteI really liked the variety of fibres you burned! Your results are very clearly presented, this would be a great example of a chart for students to use if they were completing a burn test experiment. Great discussion of care and use of each fibre too.
ReplyDeleteThis chart is dynamite! I love the characteristic category titles you came up with and how thoroughly you record your observations. This is a great way for students to complete the same activity and create a final piece for discussion and comparisons. Loved this!
ReplyDeleteFantastic chart! I've also never heard of Mo so that was interesting to learn about a new fabric. Thank you
ReplyDelete